DID HERODOTUS AND SOPHOCLES TAKE NO NOTICE OF EACH OTHER? (TO THE EVALUATION OF A RECENT HYPOTHESIS)
Table of contents
Share
QR
Metrics
DID HERODOTUS AND SOPHOCLES TAKE NO NOTICE OF EACH OTHER? (TO THE EVALUATION OF A RECENT HYPOTHESIS)
Annotation
PII
S0321-03910000408-4-1
Publication type
Article
Status
Published
Edition
Pages
133-152
Abstract
There is a common opinion that Sophocles and Herodotus were intimate with each other. Two main arguments are cited: presence of parallel places in both authors, which may be a sign of borrowing, and an epigram by Sophocles mentioning Herodotus (only its beginning is known, preserved in Plutarchs Moralia). Recently A.A. Sinizin called this common opinion in question. He noted reasonably that some of the parallel passages in Herodotus and Sophocles may well be purely coincidences. However, some other correspondences can by no means be fortuitous. As to the epigram, Sinizin denies Sophocles authorship and takes it for a late interpolation. But his arguments for such a crucial thesis are manifestly weak. Therefore, the traditional point of view still stands fi rm, and we see no forcible ground for an assertion that the dramatist and the historian were not even familiar with each other.
Date of publication
01.10.2010
Number of purchasers
2
Views
522
Readers community rating
0.0 (0 votes)
Cite   Download pdf Download JATS

References



Additional sources and materials


Belokh Yu. 2009: Grecheskaya istoriya v 2-kh tomakh. Izd. 3-e. T. 1. M.
Ven P. 2003a: Greki i mifologiya: vera ili neverie? Opyt o konstituiruyuschem voobrazhenii. M.
Ven P. 2003b: Kak pishut istoriyu. Opyt ehpistemologii. M.
Dovatur A.I., Kallistov D.P., Shishova I.A. 1982: Narody nashej strany v Istorii Gerodota. M.
Evdokimov P.A. 2004. Ehlida i upravlenie Olimpijskim svyatilischem v VIII-V vv. do n.eh. Dis. kand. ist. nauk. M.
Zelinskij F.F. 1912: Sofokl i Gerodot (novye dannye)//Germes. 15 (101), 379-380.
Ivanchik A.I. 2002: Kem byli skifskie luchniki na atticheskikh vazakh ehpokhi arkhaiki?//VDI. 3, 33-55; 4, 23-42.
Ionov I.N. 2007: Natsional'nye mify, tsivilizatsionnyj diskurs i istoricheskaya pamyat' v XVII-XIX vv.//Dialog so vremenem: Al'manakh intellektual'noj istorii. 21, 243-273.
Kasatkina N.A., Antonov V.V. 1999: Vnutripoliticheskaya bor'ba v Afinakh v seredine 40-kh gg. V v. do n.eh. i osnovanie Furij//Iz istorii antichnogo obschestva. 6, 55-63.
Kuznetsova T.I., Miller T.A. 1984: Antichnaya ehpicheskaya istoriografiya: Gerodot. Tit Livij. M.
Lur'e S.Ya. 1947a: Gerodot. M.-L.
Lur'e S.Ya. 1947b: Ocherki po istorii antichnoj nauki. M.-L.
Magaffi Dzh. P. 1882: Istoriya klassicheskogo perioda grecheskoj literatury. T. 1. M.
Rabinovich E.G. 2007: Mifotvorchestvo klassicheskoj drevnosti. SPb.
Rumyantseva M.F. 2007: Mesta pamyati v strukture natsional'no-istoricheskogo mifa//Dialog so vremenem. Al'manakh intellektual'noj istorii. 21, 106-118.
Sinitsyn A.A. 2006: Gerodot, Sofokl i egipetskie dikovinki (Ob odnomistoriograficheskom mife)//Antichnyj mir i arkheologiya. 12, 363-405.
Sinitsyn A.A. 2008a: Plut. Mor. 785 b: kriticheskie zamechaniya o dostovernosti istochnika//Mnemon. 7, 377-418.
Sinitsyn A.A. 2008b: Sofokl i skifskij logos Gerodota//Arkheologiya Vostochno-Evropejskoj stepi. 6, 269-292.
Skrzhinskaya M.V. 1985: Tema Severnogo Prichernomor'ya v tvorchestve Sofokla//VDI. 2, 142-148.
Skrzhinskaya M.V. 1991: Drevnegrecheskij fol'klor i literatura o Severnom Prichernomor'e. Kiev.
Sobolevskij S.I. 2000: Drevnegrecheskij yazyk. SPb.
Sofokl 1990: Dramy/V per. F.F. Zelinskogo. Izdanie podgotovili M.L. Gasparov,
V.N. Yarkho. M.
Strogetskij V.M. 1987: Politika Afin v Zapadnom Sredizemnomor'e v seredine V v. do n.eh. i problema osnovaniya kolonii Furii//Gorod i gosudarstvo v antichnom mire/Eh.D. Frolov (red.). L., 55-79.
Surikov I.E. 1997: Perikl i Alkmeonidy//VDI. 4, 14-35.
Surikov I.E. 1999: Atticheskaya tragediya i politicheskaya bor'ba v Afinakh//Antichnyj vestnik. 4-5, 187-193. 151
Surikov I.E. 2000: Iz istorii grecheskoj aristokratii pozdnearkhaicheskoj i klassicheskoj ehpokh. M.
Surikov I.E. 2001: Olimpijskie igry i grecheskaya skul'ptura kontsa VI-V vv. do n.eh.//Antichnost': obschestvo i idei/O.L. Gabelko (red.). Kazan', 256-274.
Surikov I.E. 2002a: Ehvolyutsiya religioznogo soznaniya afinyan vo vtoroj polovine V v. do n.eh. M.
Surikov I.E. 2002b: Tragediya Ehskhila Prositel'nitsy i politicheskaya bor'ba v Afinakh//VDI. 1, 15-24.
Surikov I.E. 2005: Klio na podmostkakh: klassicheskayagrecheskaya drama i istoricheskoe soznanie//Tsep' vremen: problemy istoricheskogo soznaniya/L.P. Repina (red.). M., 89-104.
Surikov I.E. 2006: Adam i Adam (K voprosu o spetsifike gendernykh rolej v usloviyakh antichnogo grecheskogo polisa)//Adam i Eva: Al'manakh gendernoj istorii. 12, 23-47.
Surikov I.E. 2007a: Arkhaicheskaya i klassicheskaya Gretsiya: problemy istorii i istochnikove-deniya. M.
Surikov I.E. 2007b: Gerodot i egipetskie zhretsy (k voprosu ob ottse istorii kak ottse lzhi)//Issedon. 4, 7-25.
Surikov I.E. 2008a: Antichnaya Gretsiya: politiki v kontekste ehpokhi. Vremya rastsveta demokratii. M.
Surikov I.E. 2008b: ???????????????????? v trude Fukidida (I. 21. 1) i Gerodot (Ob odnom maloizuchennom istochnike rannegrecheskogo istoriopisaniya)//VDI. 2, 25-37.
Surikov I.E. 2008v: Istoriya v drame -drama v istorii: nekotorye aspekty istoricheskogo so-znaniya v klassicheskoj Gretsii//Dialogi so vremenem. Pamyat' o proshlom v kontekste istorii/
L.P. Repina (red.). M., 371-409.
Surikov I.E. 2009a: Istorik v izmenyayuschemsya mire: ehvolyutsiya obraza Korinfa v trude Gerodota//VDI. 1, 29-53.
Surikov I.E. 2009b: Galikarnasskij zakon V v. do n.eh. (nadpis' ML 32) kak ehpigraficheskij pamyatnik i istoricheskij istochnik//Vspomogatel'nye istoricheskie distsipliny v prostranstve gumanitarnogo znaniya. Materialy XXI Mezhdunarodnoj nauchnoj konferentsii/M.F. Rumyantseva (red.). M., 330-333.
Tumans Kh. 2002: Rozhdenie Afiny. Afinskij put' k demokratii: ot Gomera do Perikla (VIII-V vv. do n.eh.). SPb.
Frolov Eh.D. 1998: Skify v Afinakh//VDI. 1, 135-152.
Bennett L.J., Tyrrell W.B. 1990: Sophocles' Antigone and Funeral Oratory//AJPh. 111, 4, 441-456.
Bichler R., Rollinger R. 2000: Herodot. Hildesheim.
Blundell M.W. 1991: Helping Friends and Harming Enemies: A Study in Sophocles and Greek Ethics. Cambr.
Braund D. 2006: In Search of the Creator of Athens' Scythian Archer-police: Speusis and the Eurymedon Vase//ZPE. 156, 109-113.
Brown T.S. 1962: The Greek Sense of Time in History as Suggested by their Accounts of Egypt//Historia. 11, 3, 257-270.
Calder W.M. 2006: Theatrokratia: Collected Papers on the Politics and Staging of Greco-Roman Tragedy. 2 ed. Hildesheim.
Desmond W. 2004: Punishments and the Conclusion of Herodotus' Histories//Greek, Roman and Byzantine Studies. 44, 19-40.
Dewald C., Kitzinger R. 2006: Herodotus, Sophocles and the Woman who Wanted her Brother Saved//The Cambridge Companion to Herodotus/C. Dewald, J. Marincola (eds.). Cambr., 122-129.
Dover K.J. 1983: Homosexualitat in der griechischen Antike. Munchen.
Egermann F. 1962: Herodot -Sophokles. Hohe Arete//Herodot: Eine Auswahl aus der neueren Forschung
W. Marg (hrsg.). Munchen, 249-255.
Ehrenberg V. 1956: Sophokles und Perikles. Munchen.
Ehrenberg V. 1965: Polis und Imperium: Beitrage zur alten Geschichte. Zurich -Stuttgart.
Fornara Ch.W. 1971: Evidence for the Data of Herodotus' Publication//JHS. 91, 25-34.
Forsdyke S. 2001: Athenian Democratic Ideology and Herodotus' Histories//AJPh. 122, 329-358.
Fowler R. 2003: Herodotos and Athens//Herodotus and his World/P. Derow, R. Parker (eds.). Oxf., 303-318.
Griffi n J. 2006: Herodotus and Tragedy//The Cambridge Companion to Herodotus/C. Dewald,
J. Marincola (eds.). Cambr., 46-59.
Hart J. 1982: Herodotus and Greek History. N.Y.
Hartog F. 1980: Le miroir d'Herodote: Essai sur la representation de l'autre. P.
Hornblower S. 2006: Herodotus' Infl uence in Antiquity//The Cambridge Companion to Herodotus/
C. Dewald, J. Marincola (eds.). Cambr., 306-318. 152
How W.W., Wells J. 1989: A Commentary on Herodotus with Introduction and Appendixes. Vol. 1. Repr. ed. Oxf. -N.Y.
Irwin T.H. 1985: Permanent Happiness: Aristotle and Solon//Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy. 3, 89-124.
Jacoby F. 1913: Herodotos//RE. Supplbd 2. 205-520.
Ker J. 2000: Solon's Theoria and the End of the City//Classical Antiquity. 19, 2, 304-329.
Kukofka D.-A. 1992: Sophokles: Oidipus auf Kolonos. Eine Interpretation vor dem Hintergrund der Polis Athen am Ende des funften Jahrhunderts//Gymnasium. 69, 101-118.
Lendle O. 1992: Einfuhrung in die griechische Geschichtsschreibung. Darmstadt.
Lloyd A.B. 1975: Herodotus Book II. Introduction. Leiden.
Loraux N. 1981: L'invention d'Athenes: Histoire de l'oraison funebre dans la cite classique. P.
Marincola J. 2001: Greek Historians. Oxf.
Moles J. 2002: Herodotus and Athens//Brill's Companion to Herodotus/E.J. Bakker, I.J.F de Jong, H. van Wees (eds.). Leiden -Boston, 33-52.
Ostwald M. 1991: Herodotus and Athens//ICS. 16, 1/2, 111-124.
Piccirilli L. 1976: Erodoto e l'apodemia di Solone//Contributi di storia antica in onore di A. Garzetti. Genova, 23-30.
Podlecki A.J. 1977: Herodotus in Athens?//Greece and the Eastern Mediterranean in Ancient History and Prehistory: Studies Presented to F. Schachermeyr on the Occasion of his 80th Birthday. K.H. Kinzl (ed.). B., 246-265.
Reeker H.-D. 1971: Solons Reisen//Antike und Abendland. 17, 2, 96-104.
Rhodes P.J. 2003: Ancient Democracy and Modern Ideology. L.
Robinson E.W. 1997: The First Democracies: Early Popular Government outside Athens. Stuttgart.
Said S. 2002: Herodotus and Tragedy//Brill's Companion to Herodotus/E.J. Bakker, I.J.F de Jong, H. van Wees (eds.). Leiden -Boston, 117-147.
Schachermeyr F. 1968: Religionspolitik und Religiositdt bei Perikles. Wien.
Solmsen F. 1974: Two Crucial Decisions in Herodotus. Amsterdam-London.
Stadter Ph. 1991: Pericles among the Intellectuals//ICS. 16, 1/2, 111-124.
Strasburger H. 1955: Herodot und das perikleische Athen//Historia. 4, 1, 1-25.
Surikov I. 2009: Herodotus' Histories and Athenian Aristocracy//International Quadrennial Conference: Hellenic Dimension: Studies in Language, Literature, Culture. Riga, 32.
Vannicelli P. 2007: Herodotus' Egypt and the Foundations of Universal History//The Historian's Craft in the Age of Herodotus/N. Luraghi (ed.). Oxf., 211-240.
Wade-Gery H.T. 1958: Essays in Greek History. Oxf.
Weber L. 1935: Solon und die Schopfung der attischen Grabrede. Frankfurt am Main.
Whitman C.H. 1951: Sophocles: A Study of Heroic Humanism. Cambr. Mass.
Will W. 1995: Perikles. Reinbek.
Will W. 2003: Thukydides und Perikles: Der Historiker und sein Held. Bonn.
Ziolkowski J. 1981: Thucydides and the Tradition of Funeral Speeches in Athens. N.Y.

Comments

No posts found

Write a review
Translate