Везде
On accuracy in philology
Table of contents
Annotation Estimate Publication content
References Comments
Share
QR
Metrics
On accuracy in philology
Annotation
PII
S0373-658X0000437-3-1
Publication type
Article
Status
Published
Authors
Nikolay Pertsov 
Edition
Issue 3
Pages
100-124
Abstract
The work was written in connection with the articles of M.I. Shapira and A.V. Smooth, dedicated to the possibilities of applying exact methods in the humanities; both articles were published in "Questions of Linguistics" - the first in 2005, the second, sharply polemical in relation to the first, in 2007. The concept of "accuracy" is analyzed as applied to the sciences of the humanities. A number of examples demonstrate the complexity of truly accurate, rigorous, formal constructions in linguistics in particular and in philology in general. The main methodological theses outlined in Shapir's article are discussed in connection with Gladkiy's reaction to them; in most cases, the author of this work agrees with Shapir, although on some points he fundamentally disagrees with him. The conclusion is drawn about the fruitfulness of M.I. Shapir of the prospects of mathematics in the field of building a general theory in the humanities and the doubtfulness of the "natural-scientific" optimism of A.V. Smooth about this.
Keywords
linguistics and mathematics metalanguage linguistics methodology philology formalization
Date of publication
04.05.2009
Number of purchasers
2
Views
587
Readers community rating
0.0 (0 votes)
Cite   Download pdf

References



Additional sources and materials

Aleksandrov 1964 - A.ID.] Aleksandrov. Matematika//Filosofskaya enciklopediya. M., 1964.

IT.] 3: Kommunizm - Nauka.

Apresyan 2001 - YU.D. Apresyan. Sistemoobrazuyushchie smysly ‘znat'’ i ‘schitat'’ v russkom yazyke // Russk. yaz. v nauchn. osveshchenii. 2001. № 1.

Gasparov 1984 - ML. Gasparov. Eshche raz o sporah o russkoj sillabotonike // Problemy teorii stiha. L.. 1984.

Gladkij 2007 - A.V. Gpadkij. O tochnyh i matematicheskih metodah v lingvistike i drugih gumanitarnyh naukah // VYA. 2007. X? 5.

Gladkij, Mel'chuk 1969 - A.V. Gladkij. I.A. Mel'chuk. Elementy matematicheskoj lingvistiki. M., 1969.

Dobrovol'skij 2007 - D.O. Dobrovol'skij. Passivizaciya idiom (o semanticheskoj obuslovlennosti sintaksicheskih transformacij vo frazeologii) // VYA. 2007. № 5.

Zaliznyak 1973 - A.A. Zaliznyak. O ponimanii termina «padezh» v lingvisticheskih opisaniyah I // Problemy grammaticheskogo modelirovaniya. M., 1973.

Zaliznyak 1977 -AL. Zaliznyak. Grammaticheskij slovar' russkogo yazyka. Slovoizmenenie. M., 1977 (Poslednee 4-e izd.. ispr. i dop. - 2003).

Zaliznyak 2000-LL. Zaliznyak. Lingvistika po A.T. Fomenko//Istoriya i antiistoriya: Kritika «novoj hronologii» akademika A.T. Fomenko. M., 2000.

Kolmogorov 1954 - A.N. Kolmogorov. Matematika // Bol'shaya sovetskaya enciklopediya. 2-e izd. M., 1954. T. 26: Magnitka - Meduza.

Mel'chuk 1997 - I.A. Mel'chuk. Kurs obshchej morfologii. T. I. Vvedenie. CHast' pervaya: Slovo. (Per. s franc.) M.; Vena, 1997.

Percov 1996a - N.V. Percov. Element ka- v russkom yazyke: slovoforma ili affiks? // Rusistika. Slavistika. Indoevropeistika: Sb. k 60-lstiyu A.A. Zaliznyaka. M., 1996.

Percov 19966 - I.V. Percov. O nekotoryh problemah sovremennoj semantiki i komp'yuternoj lingvistiki // Moskovskij lingvisticheskij al'manah. Vyp. 1: Spornoe v lingvistike. M., 1996.

Percov 2003 - N.V. Percov. Vozvratnye stradatel'nye formy russkogo glagola v svyazi s problemoj sushchestvovaniya v morfologii // VYA. 2003. № 4.

Percov 2006a - N.V. Percov. K suzhdeniyam o faktah russkogo yazyka v svete korpusnyh dannyh // Russk. yaz. v nauchn. osveshchenii. 2006. № 1(11).

Percov 20066 - N.V. Percov. O roli korpusov v lingvisticheskih issledovaniyah // Trudy mezhdunar. konf. «Korpusnaya lingvistika - 2006». SPb., 2006.

Percov 2007 - N.V. Percov. Poeziya orfografii i orfografiya poezii //Lingvistika i poetika v nachale tret'ego tysyacheletiya. Mat-ly mezhdunar. nauchn. konf. (In-t russkogo yazyka im. V.V. Vinogradova RAN. Moskva, 24-28 maya 2007 g.). M., 2007.

Percov 2008 - N.V. Percov. O sootnoshenii pis'mennoj i ustnoj form poeticheskogo yazyka (K voprosu o funkcional'noj nagruzhennosti starogo russkogo pravopisaniya) // VYA. 2008. Iz 2.

Suhotin 1978 - B.V. Suhotin. Osnovnye problemy grammatiki i semantiki v tenzornom ischislenii // Problemy strukturnoj lingvistiki 1976. M., 1978.

SYAP - Slovar' yazyka Pushkina. T. 2: 3-N. M., 1957.

Trub 2006 - V.M. Trub. O vozmozhnom podhode k semanticheskomu opisaniyu chastej tela // Moskovskij lingvisticheskij zhurnal. 2006. T. 8. № 1.

SHapir 2000 - M.I. SHapir. Universum versus: YAzyk - stih - smysl v russkoj poezii XVIII— XX vekov. M., 2000. Kn. 1.

SHapir 2001 - M.I. SHapir. YAzyk etiki ili etika yazyka? O deontologii nauki // YAzyk i kul'tura. Fakty i cennosti. M., 2001.

SHapir 2002a - M.I. SHapir. «Evgenij Onegin»: problema autentichnogo teksta // IAN SLYA. T. 61. 2002. №3.

SHapir 20026 - M.I. SHapir. Filologiya kak fundament gumanitarnogo znaniya: Ob osnovnyh napravleniyah issledovanij po teoreticheskoj i prikladnoj filologii // Antropologiya kul'tury. Vyp. I. M.. 2002.

SHapir 2005 - M.I. SHapir. «Tebe chisla i mery net»: O vozmozhnostyah i granicah «tochnyh metodov» v gumanitarnyh naukah // VYA. 2005. № 1.

SHapir 2006 - M.I. SHapir. «Tebe chisla i mery net»: O vozmozhnostyah i granicah «tochnyh metodov» v gumanitarnyh naukah // B.I. YArho. Metodologiya tochnogo literaturovedeniya... M., 2006.

YAKMSL - YAzykovaya kartina mira i sistemnaya leksikografiya. M., 2006.

YArho 2006 - B.I. YArho. Metodologiya tochnogo literaturovedeniya: Izbr. tr. po teorii literatury / Izd. podgot. M.V. Akimova, I.A. Pil'shchikov i M.I. SHapir: pod obshchej red. M.I. SHapira. M.. 2006.

Comments

No posts found

Write a review
Translate